Review by Eric Monse for HTC DROID INCREDIBLE Android Phone (Verizon Wireless)
Rating:
I had an iPhone and recently got the HTC Incredible. I loved the iPhone but hated AT&T. But I love the HTC Incredible even better than I loved my iPhone. Here’s why.

HTC Incredible advantages over iPhone ——————

Verizon – I got rid of my iPhone simply because AT&T is terrible here in New York. My sister and her husband in Washington DC got an iPhone over Christmas and they complain about the crappy service there too. Verizon is blazing fast, the best service in NYC.

Widgets – Surprisingly the iPhone doesn’t have widgets. The Incredible has some really cool widgets you can use. Widgets are like icons you can add to home screens, but instead of opening a program, the icon itself will give you info or have some other type of functionality like a a list of contacts or booksmarks you can access directly without opening a program first.

Transfer files without iTunes – Whether you like iTunes or not, you are hamstrung using it with the iPhone. With the Incredible, transfer is simple. You connect the phone to your computer and you can copy over files to it.

Connect it to as many computers as you want – I can connect to my computer both at home and at work, something you can’t do with the iPhone. Apple annoyingly limits you to one computer to update your iPhone.

Access the file system – Unlike the iPhone, you can copy, paste and delete files from the internal hard drive. You can also copy files from the hard drive to your computer–or any computer for that matter.

Email – E-mail capabilities on the Incredible are better than the iPhone. In addition to global search, you can sort by conversation, sender, date, etc.

8 megapixel Camera with flash – The 8 megapixel camera takes beautiful detailed shots, even better than the iPhone’s camera, which actually takes really nice photos as long as it’s not dark. The iPhone doesn’t have a flash. The camera on the Incredible did crash a few times, a but I’m hoping they will work out in later versions. The Incredible camera is also really fast loading.

Physical Camera button – The Incredible has a physical camera and video record button that works very well. With the iPhone you need to push a button on the touch screen, kind of annoying sometimes.

Faster – The Incredible is blazing fast. There is rarely any lag in switching or loading programs. Very snappy.

Mp3 player access without unlocking screen – When you’re listening to music and you click the button to turn on the screen, you don’t need to unlock the screen to see what music is playing. The iPhone has that as well. But unlike the iPhone, it also has usable back, pause and forward buttons on the locked screen.

Editable dictionary – You can see and edit the keyboard dictionary yourself and choose what words you want in it.

Send caller to voice mail – If you edit a user’s contact, you have an option to always send that user to voice mail if you want. Minor, but kinda cool.

Weather on calendar – When you flip through upcoming days on your calendar, it also displays the weather for that day. Pretty sweet.

Google maps with layers – Android allows you to add `layers’ to your map. For example, you can overlay the NYC MTA subway maps and see the actual subway lines. iPhone can’t do that.

Super thin – This phone feels thinner than the iPhone, and I think it is in some ways. It certainly fits in my pocket a lot nicer than the Motorola Droid, which felt about 1/3 thicker than the incredible.

iPhone advantages over HTC Incredible ——————

Music audio quality – I loaded the same some songs on both the Incredible and the iPhone and listened carefully. The iPhone’s music audio quality, without any EQ, is slightly better than the Incredible. It’s not bad on the incredible, it just sounds slightly punchier across the audio spectrum on the iPhone. The Incredible does have better sound quality than the Motorola Droid, which I also tested.

Equalizer – The iPhone has different equalizer settings. It’s poorly implemented and easy to get low-end distortion but at least they have an EQ. No EQ on Android phones. Lame.

Alerts – I like the way alerts and text messages pop up on the iPhone better than the Android. It feels like you need to dig too much to access new messages on the Incredible.

Apps – Of course, the iPhone’s app store is far more extensive than the Android’s. 95% of the functionality I can still get on the Android, but apps for the Android are almost always made second to iPhone apps if at all.

Review by Laura Dale for HTC DROID INCREDIBLE Android Phone (Verizon Wireless)
Rating:
I got my Droid Incredible in the mail on Tuesday even though the release date is today (4/29).

The phone is stunning…with all the simplicity you’d expect out of a new smartphone and all the fun you’d expect out of a Google phone.

Pros:

Android OS and Sense

Customizable

Beautiful Screen

Android Market

8MP camera (shoots well in low light don’t let anyone tell you different)

super fast processor

7 home screens that you can view by pinching. You don’t have to swipe through all 7. Makes my friends jealous.

the browser is smooth and fast. Auto aligns text when you zoom. uses multi-touch to pinch and zoom. Smooth scrolling and fast, fast load times.

Cons

hard to sync any e-mail other than a gmail account

facebook app sucks, but i just made a bookmark to the full site, since the internet is super fast

optical trackpad is glitchy but i only use it for the camera

battery life…but Seidio is coming out with an extended battery so thats not going to be a problem soon

Bottom Line:

Honestly, I have been waiting for a phone like this every since the iPhone. I don’t have AT&T and to be honest I just don’t like Apple as a company. They make cool stuff, but they rip their customers off. This phone is an iPhone killer. Compare them on all levels of performance, looks, functionality, customization, and speed and you’ll find that the Droid Incredible is the same if not better. Also, Verizon’s coverage is fantastic, so don’t be fooled by 4G. I’m sure its great if you live somewhere where you get service.

EDIT: (4/30) This phone eats RAM like crazy. I installed “Advanced Task Killer” but I was still down to only 42M after a few days. I would suggest downloading either “Task Manager” or “TaskPanel” (I have Task Manager and my boyfriend has TaskPanel on his Moto Droid and both work quite well). I also suggest restarting the phone every few days just like you would a real computer.

Other than that still no complaints

Review by W. Westlake for HTC DROID INCREDIBLE Android Phone (Verizon Wireless)
Rating:
This is my first smartphone having been a fence sitter with my old voice / text phone till now. I’d been waiting in anticipation for Verizon to confirm / deny the rumors about the Nexus One since February. Then I started reading online reviews / comparisons between the Nexus One and the newly announced Incredible and felt myself leaning more the the Incredible though the two phones are very similar.

I was happily surprised when Verizon finally broke the silence and announced the availability of the Incredible. And though I was only halfway through my New Every Two plan, upon my request Verizon graciously offered me the phone at the promotional $149 and then simply restarted my New Every Two the moment I activated this phone. THAT’S good customer service.

I’ve had the phone for over a week and I absolutely love it. Yes there are grumblings about the lean battery life. I won’t lie, you do need to be prepared to charge it daily, especially for the first few days. But you have to keep in mind it’s a small computer that does REAL multitasking. This is nothing new for those who have owned smartphones previously and does take a little getting used to by the basic voice / text phone crowd (my old voice / text phone went 8-9 days between charging).

The battery is a tad undersized for the power of the phone but then again we consumers want a small, thin form factor. Already there’s a 1750 mAh battery available (exact same dimensions as the one it ships with) and rumors of an upcoming 2100+ mAh. And remember, something you can do with this and most every non-Apple mobile device – easily carry a spare & swap / upgrade batteries.

Following the advice on the Android forums, for the first few days I put my phone through full charge / discharge (till completely dead) cycles and have noticed a good 50% gain on battery life.

The screen is gorgeous. Because the phone does true multitasking you have a selection of animated backgrounds including a really cool swirling galaxy, blades of grass waving in the breeze, etc. Touch sensitivity is great albeit a little too sensitive at times (a screen protector really helps in this area). The multi-touch is great and while surfing the web, with most sites you can “drag zoom” (opposite of a pinch) text and pictures and then pan around – especially for those sites that prefer to use annoyingly small microfiche fonts.

Voice quality is excellent – both what you hear and what your caller hears

The speaker is decent for a phone but plug in a decent pair of headphones (uses a standard jack) and you have sound quality rivaling an iPod. Plus the cord on the headphones acts as an antenna for the built-in FM radio.

wifi setup is a breeze though with Verizon’s unlimited data plan the biggest benefit to wifi connectivity is speed. I find the range with my home network is as good as my laptop and the phone will automatically switch between known / configured wifi networks and the regular 3G network, with a preference for wifi over 3G. When using the YouTube app, if you’re connected on wifi it will automatically always try to get the highest quality version of the video. If you’re only on the 3G network then you have to tell the player to use higher quality (since it can take longer to load and possibly not stream as smoothly on 3G).

I’ve been using the free Pandora app to stream internet radio and have quickly gotten addicted to always-on Internet connectivity. Sound quality doesn’t change between wifi and 3G and I can’t even tell when the phone switches as I get out of range of my configured wifi hotspots. There is something to be said for the Verizon 3G network coverage. I live in Phoenix and haven’t had any connectivity issues.

I do need to mention there’s a current issue in the app that shows you 3G signal strength in the phone status bar. It doesn’t seem to show true signal strength. That is at times it has shown zero signal strength and I’ve made calls, surfed, listened to Internet radio with no quality issues. Once again, this is a new phone and nothing an update (they download via the 3G / wifi network, by the way – you don’t have to plug it into your computer or take it to the Verizon store) won’t correct.

Voice recognition is pretty flawless (actually performed by the Verizon server farm, I believe) and can be used pretty much anywhere you can use the onscreen keyboard.

Integration with Gmail email, contacts & calendar is seamless. In fact if you have a Gmail account you’ll see there’s no longer any need to keep contacts on your phone. You can assign ringtones, notes, etc to your Gmail contacts exactly as you can to contacts stored locally on the phone so why bother backing up with Backup Assistant, etc? Every time the phone syncs with your Gmail account any changes are “backed up”. You do have the option to sync with other email providers but I haven’t explored that feature since I only use Gmail.

I’ve had hit and miss success with Flash video on sites like [...]. But at least the Android OS is committed to supporting Flash so I have full confidence that this will be corrected in an upcoming update.

All this chatter about the Apple store having hundreds of thousands of apps vs Google store only having twenty thousand or so seems rather irrelevant to me. That is, I’m finding PLENTY of apps available and a surprising quantity of great quality FREE apps. And as the Android OS gets more and more popular, and as Apple gets more and more unfriendly toward their “loyal” developers, there are going to be more and more apps available for the Android OS.

Finally, at least in my case Verizon only shipped the anemic printed “Quick Start” guide which did little more than tell you to charge it fully first and gave a quick overview of the phone and setting up Gmail, Facebook, etc. If you do a Google search for “Droid Incredible Users Guide” you’ll find a great 206 page PDF of the full users guide. I’m not sure why Verizon isn’t shipping it (printed OR CD) though it has their logo on it. If you’re new to smartphones and/or the Android OS (like I was) this guide is a must and can help you make the most out of this incredible (ha!) little device.

If you’re still a fence sitter like I was, yes, there will always be a better phone “coming”. But if you’re ready to finally join the smartphone crowd I think the Droid Incredible is an excellent phone to make the leap with.